Judge denies Shirvell request to seal deposition
Former assistant attorney general is being sued by Chris Armstrong
By Tara Cavanaugh
Originally printed 7/7/2011 (Issue 1927 - Between The Lines News)
Last Wednesday a federal judge denied Andrew Shirvell's request to have his deposition sealed, reported the Detroit Free Press.
The Free Press quoted the judge's four-page ruling: "Defendant argues that the alleged abuse, threats, and harassment by third parties, not involved in this litigation, are a basis for the Court to issue a protective order. The Court finds no merit in Defendant's argument. Defendant's failure to identify 'specific facts' showing 'clearly defined and serious injury' that would result from the discovery sought prevents the Court from exercising its discretion in granting the relief requested."
Shirvell's request for a protective order was denied as well.
Sealing a deposition means that the deposition would not be made public record. Depositions are rarely sealed from public access, and almost never in their entirety. It is more common for limited parts of a deposition to be sealed, such as in the case of a company's trade secrets.
Shirvell is being sued by Chris Armstrong for stalking, harassment and defamation of character. Last fall, Shirvell wrote a blog about Armstrong called "Chris Armstrong Watch" and protested what Shirvell called Armstrong's "radical homosexual agenda." He also appeared on Anderson Cooper 360 to defend his actions. Last year Armstrong was the first openly gay president of the University of Michigan Student Assembly; he graduated this spring.
Shirvell was eventually fired from his position after an investigation by the attorney general's office found that he used state computers to blog about Armstrong.
Armstrong filed his suit against Shirvell on April 1, and on May 6 Shirvell asked that the suit be dismissed and he filed a countersuit. In his countersuit, Shirvell alleges that Armstrong is to blame for losing his job with the state of Michigan.
Armstrong's lawyer, Deborah Gordon, responded to the Shirvell's most recent request in a filing: "Defendant sets forth zero legitimate basis for his highly unusual request to seal his deposition in its entirety. If embarrassment of a deponent was a criteria, virtually every deposition taken would be sealed.
"(Shirvell's) brief actually makes it crystal clear that of all people his deposition should not be sealed. It is riddled with false statements, fabrications, dramatic hyperbole, accusations against others, paranoia and delusions of victimization. Mr. Shirvell contends that he has never bullied Chris Armstrong, but rather that he is being bullied ... Shirvell's brief also reveals that (he) continues to monitor and obsess over (Armstrong's) activities to this day.
"Shirvell has had no problem publicly attacking (Armstrong) for all the world to hear and see, but now wants the truth or lack thereof behind his accusations to never see the light of day ... It is telling and bizarre that (Shirvell) believes he will be embarrassed or harmed by his own statements made under oath."
Shirvell now lives in New York. The Michigan Bar Association is investigating whether or not Shirvell should be disbarred from practicing law.
- ALERT Missing Person In Metro Detroit
- A Remembrance: Robert Clark
- New LGBT Tobacco Disparity Report For Michigan Released
- Representation: Trans Activism In Michigan Lame Duck
- Between Bass And Treble: An Alto Story
- Local Gatherings Against MiRFRA
- Call To Action: Petition Seeks To Stop MIRFRA
- Top Faith Leaders Discuss Religious Freedom, LGBT Inclusion
- The First Trans Helpline In USA Is In Michigan
- LGBT Judge To Speak At Ann Arbor Interfaith Service
- Gay Therapist Discusses Sexualities Of LGBT And Straight Men In New Book
- Affirmations Seeks LGBTQ-Friendly Healthcare Providers
- Ruth Ellis Center Celebrates 15 Years Serving LGBTQ Youth
- The Rise Of 'License To Discriminate'; The Failure Of LGBT Civil Rights
- State Civil Rights Amendment Dead, Says Speaker
- WCC Expands LGBT Protections
- PrEP Debate Continues As Advocates Hold Conversations In State
- 'KICK' Off The Holidays With Annual Gala In Detroit
- Foster Children's Charity Collecting New Toys, Gifts For Holiday Bazaar
- Right Reverend Wendell Gibbs To Speak On Marriage Equality
- Affirmations Hosts Information Session On LGBT Foster Parenting And Adoption
- Campus; Student and Alumni Groups
- Western Michigan University, Office of LBGT Student Services
- Carpeting & Rugs
- Merkel Furniture and Carpet One
- AG Chocolates
- University Musical Society
- Hotlines & Switchboards
- Alcoholic Anonymous
- National Organizations
- Religious & Spiritual
- First Unitarian Universalist Church
- Ann Arbor Queer Aquatics
Enter contests to win great prizes like CDs, DVDs, concert tickets and more
- Exclusive! 'Looking' Star Russell Tovey On Sex Scenes, His Famous Butt & That Rimming Cake
- Q&A: Andy Cohen On His (Almost) Tell-All Book, 'Nasty' Names Gays Call Him
- Divine Intervention: Bette Midler Talks Early Gay Support, 'Diva' Degradation & Twerking ('Girls, Please!')
- Creep of the Week: The Duggars
- Being Young & Coming Out To Bette Midler
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!
A study published in the journal The Lancet HIV reports that there is a significant disparity in HIV prevalence between black and white men who have sex with men. The study was published on Nov. 18 and found a startling 32 percent prevalence rate for black men who have sex with men, compared with only eight percent for white men who have sex with men.View More World AIDS Day
This Week's Issue
Download or view this week's print issue today!
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!