Arkansas Court Upholds Gay Marriage Birth Certificate Law
By JILL BLEED
Originally printed 12/15/2016 (Issue 2450 - Between The Lines News)
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) - Arkansas' highest court on Dec. 8 threw out a judge's ruling that could have allowed all married same-sex couples to get the names of both spouses on their children's birth certificates without a court order, saying it doesn't violate equal protection "to acknowledge basic biological truths."
The state Supreme Court also issued a rare admonishment to Pulaski County Circuit Judge Tim Fox, saying he made "inappropriate remarks" in his ruling that struck down the birth certificate law. Fox had cited the U.S. Supreme Court's decision legalizing gay marriage in his ruling last year that said married same-sex couples should have both names listed on their children's birth certificates, just as heterosexual married couples do, without requiring a court order.
In the state Supreme Court's decision, the justices sided with the state attorney general's office, saying Arkansas has a vested interest in listing biological parents on birth certificates.
"What is before this court is a narrow issue of whether the birth-certificate statutes as written deny the appellees due process," Justice Josephine Linker Hart wrote in the court's majority opinion. "...In the situation involving the female spouse of a biological mother, the female spouse does not have the same biological nexus to the child that the biological mother or the biological father has. It does not violate equal protection to acknowledge basic biological truths."
Cheryl Maples, who sued on behalf of three same-sex couples, said she hasn't decided yet whether to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. The three couples who sued were allowed to amend their children's birth certificates last year under a ruling issued by Fox.
"There's no requirement that DNA be given or that there be a biological relationship to a child to get on a birth certificate for a father, for the non-birth parent," she said. "All you have to do is legitimize the child and you're entitled, if you're heterosexual. This is wrong."
Judd Deere, a spokesman for Arkansas Attorney General Leslie Rutledge, said the state is "gratified" by the court's decision.
"If any changes are appropriate it is the job of legislators to do so, not the circuit court," he said.
Associate Justice Paul Danielson dissented and Justice Rhonda Wood concurred in part and dissented in part.
"There can be no reasonable dispute that the inclusion of a parent's name on a child's birth certificate is a benefit associated with and flowing from marriage," Danielson wrote, adding that the U.S. Supreme Court decision legalizing gay marriage "requires that this benefit be accorded to same-sex spouses and opposite-sex spouses with equal force."
The birth certificate issue was the first major case surrounding gay marriage for the Arkansas court since an unusually public split among justices last year over its handling of a lawsuit over Arkansas' same-sex marriage ban. The court dismissed the gay marriage lawsuit hours after the U.S. Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.
- Trump Nominates Defense, HHS, HUD
- Next North Carolina Governor Says He Can Carry Out Agenda
- Report: LGBT Students Still Face Discrimination at School
- One Million Moms Lashes Out Against Zales Over 'Love and Pride' Collection
- Arkansas Court Upholds Gay Marriage Birth Certificate Law
- Video Company Challenges Gay Marriage Law
- Boston Students Walk out of Classes to Protest Trump
- 4 Churches Drop Lawsuit Challenging State's Transgender Law
- ACLU want Obama to Commute Sentence for Chelsea Manning
- 6 Months Later, 49 Killed at Pulse are Remembered in Orlando
- Webster University Investigation of Racist Fliers Continues
- From 'Oops' to DOE Chief; Rick Perry is Pick for Energy
- Trump Met Dec. 7 with NC Gov. McCrory
- 305 Claims Approved for Pulse Victims' Fund
- Walmart Cites Settlement Agreement in Same-Sex Benefits Case
- Trump's Inauguration Set to Test Nation's Readiness to Heal
- Trump Appointments: A Troubling Trend
- Bono Recruits Julia Roberts, Channing Tatum for AIDS Fight
- Major HIV Vaccine Trial in South Africa Stokes Hope
- Trump Disavowal of White Supremacists Doesn't Quiet Concerns
- Grand Traverse Resort & Casinos
- Event Planners
- The Wedding Connection
- Foundations and Funders
- The HOPE Fund
- Health & Beauty
- It Works Global - Ultimate Body Applicator
- Insurance Exchange Agency
- J. Thomas Jewelers
- Senior Living
- Seniors Helping Seniors
- Ringwald Theatre
- Michigan Theater
Enter contests to win great prizes like CDs, DVDs, concert tickets and more
- Q&A: Joe Jonas on Fans Who Send Him Naked Selfies, 'Fun' Gay Rumors & Exploring S&M
- The LGBT Guide to Election Night 2016
- Megan Mullally on the 'Very Good Chance' a 10-Episode Revival of 'Will & Grace' Is Happening, James Franco's Gayness & Lesbian Advances
- EQMI Political Mixer Raises Concerns
- Nathan Sykes on Equality, Support For His LGBT Fans & How an Ariana Grande Song Fueled Gay Rumors About Him
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!
This Week's Issue
Download or view this week's print issue today!
Sign up to receive our weekly newsletters today!